Negative Electricity Prices: Why Power Sometimes Costs Less Than Nothing

Published:

At first glance it sounds paradoxical: a seller pays someone to take their electricity. That is exactly what happens when the wholesale electricity price turns negative. In Germany and several other European markets this is no longer a rare event. This guide explains how negative prices arise and what they mean for you.

What does a negative electricity price mean?

In the day-ahead auction, supply and demand meet for every quarter-hour of the following day (see What is the day-ahead spot price?). A negative price means that during that period so much power is on offer that generators are willing to pay for it to be taken rather than reduce their output.

A price of −€20/MWh therefore means the seller pays the buyer €20 per megawatt hour.

How do negative prices arise?

Negative prices occur when high supply meets low demand and some generators still do not respond. Typical causes:

Lots of wind and solar power

Wind and solar plants have almost no fuel costs. On sunny and windy days they feed in large volumes at the same time, especially around midday.

Low demand

Industrial and commercial consumption drops at weekends, on public holidays and during holiday periods. Combined with high generation, this quickly produces a surplus.

Inflexible generation

Not every plant can ramp down at short notice. Some keep running because

  • shutting down and restarting later would cost more than a few hours at a negative price,
  • they also supply heat, as combined heat and power plants do,
  • they provide services that keep the grid stable.

Support schemes

Some older subsidised plants receive payments regardless of the market price, so they have little incentive to switch off when prices are negative. Newer rules address this (see below).

Limited flexibility in the system

Storage, flexible consumers and exports can absorb surpluses – but only up to a point. When interconnectors are full and storage is charged, the surplus stays in the domestic market and pushes prices down.

When do negative prices typically occur?

A common pattern:

  • Season: more often in spring and summer, when solar output is high.
  • Time of day: mainly around midday and early afternoon.
  • Day of week: especially weekends and public holidays.
  • Weather: sunny, and windy as well.

Negative prices at night are less common but do occur when it is very windy and demand is low. Since the switch to quarter-hour prices in October 2025, it is also visible that negative periods often do not start or end exactly on the hour.

The Germany electricity price page highlights quarter-hours with negative prices in its daily statistics.

What negative prices mean for households

On a fixed tariff

With a classic fixed-price tariff you do not notice negative wholesale prices directly. Your price per kilowatt hour stays the same.

On a dynamic tariff

With a dynamic electricity tariff, your energy price falls during these periods. However, network charges, levies, taxes and VAT still apply. The final price therefore almost always stays positive – but it can be well below the usual level. The guide What makes up the retail electricity price? explains how large these fixed components are.

If you are flexible, you can make use of such periods, for example for charging an electric car, running a heat pump or charging a home battery.

What negative prices mean for solar systems

For solar panel owners, negative prices are becoming increasingly relevant. In Germany, the so-called Solar Peak Act (Solarspitzengesetz) amended the Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG). For many new systems commissioned since 25 February 2025, feed-in payments are suspended during periods with a negative day-ahead price (Section 51 EEG). In return, the support period is extended by the affected time.

There are exceptions and transitional rules, including for small systems and depending on the installed metering equipment, and different rules partly apply to existing systems. Check the current legal text at gesetze-im-internet.de (in German) or seek advice for your specific case. Other EU countries have their own rules.

For solar owners, it can make sense during negative prices to use your own solar power or store it in a battery rather than export it.

Are negative prices good or bad?

Both. Negative prices show that at times more renewable power is available than the system can absorb. They signal that more flexibility is needed: storage, controllable demand, more grid capacity and more flexible power plants. At the same time they create costs, for example when subsidised plants are paid despite negative prices.

For consumers with flexible devices and a dynamic tariff, they are mainly an opportunity to use electricity particularly cheaply.

Summary

  • Negative prices arise from high supply, low demand and inflexible generation.
  • They occur mostly around midday on sunny weekends and holidays.
  • Households on a fixed tariff are unaffected; on a dynamic tariff the energy price falls.
  • The final price usually stays positive because of network charges, levies and taxes.
  • Many new German solar systems receive no feed-in payment during negative-price periods.

Note: This guide is general information only and does not constitute legal, financial or energy advice. No guarantee of accuracy.

Frequently asked questions

Do I get paid for using electricity when prices are negative?
Usually not. On a fixed tariff you will not notice anything. On a dynamic tariff your energy price drops, but network charges, levies and taxes still apply, so the final price normally stays positive.
When are negative prices most likely?
Typically on sunny, windy days with low demand – especially around midday at weekends and on public holidays in spring and summer. They are never guaranteed, though.
Why don't power plants simply switch off when prices are negative?
Some plants cannot ramp down quickly or cheaply, others must keep running for technical reasons, to supply heat or to provide grid services. In addition, some older subsidised plants still receive payments when prices are negative.
Does a new solar system in Germany get paid during negative prices?
For many systems commissioned in Germany since 25 February 2025, feed-in payments are suspended during negative-price periods (Section 51 EEG), with exceptions and compensation through a longer support period. Always check the current legal text.